Improving the Electrical Motor with Magnets

We will test if having magnets near motors affects their performance
Caius Franco Rowan Scruggs
Grade 8

Hypothesis

If two high strength neyodymium magnets are placed on either side of a DC motor, then its revolutions per minute (RPM) will increase due to the extra force pulling the motor around.

Research

- Jared Owen, "How Does an Electric Motor Work? (DC Motor)," https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWulQ1ZSE3c.

- David MacAulay, The Way Things Work, Revised Edition (Clarion Books, 2023). 

- Science Max, "Electromagnet," https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaPfo2hwDSI.

Variables

INDEPENDANT:

- distance of magnets from motor

DEPENTANT:

- RPM of motor

CONTROL:

- RPM of motor without magnets

CONSTANTS:

- same motor

- same magnets

- same batteries

- same setup

Procedure

1. First we will use a 3D printed jig to mount the magnets on both sides of the motor. This will keep them at a set distance during the test.

2. Then we will power the motor with 8 AA batteries to provide 12V of current to the motor.

3. Then we will use a tachometer with a 5cm diameter attachment on the motor shaft to test the RPM. 

4. Finally, we will repeat steps 2 and 3 with the magnets at five separate distances. We will start at 0mm from the motor and incrementally increase the distance by 7.25mm for each test. We will repeat each test five times.

Observations

- The motor shook around quite a bit; next time we will hold it in place with a jig.

- We will also add a jig for holding the tachometer (tool for measuring RPM) at a fixed distance to prevent shaking.

- We will use a proper power supply to ensure battery drain does not affect the results.

Analysis

Control: Without the magnets, the average speed of our motor was 7 981 RPM. 

Distance 1: With the magnets adjacent to the motor (0mm), the average speed almost doubled to 14 310 RPM.

Distance 2: At a distance of 7.25mm, the average speed slowed to 10 038 RPM (while still exceeding the control). 

Distance 3: At a distance of 14.55mm, the average speed slowed further to 8 935 RPM (still exceeding the control).

Distance 4: At a distance of 21.75, the average speed increased slightly beyond distance 3 to 10 038 RPM. This was an unespected result which requires further testing to ensure the accuracy of our results.

Distance 5: At a distance of 29mm, the average speed slowed to 8 983 RPM. Still, we note that the average speed still exceeds our initial control test. 

 

  Without magnets Magnets 0mm Magnets 7.25mm Magnets 14.5mm Magnets 21.75mm Magnets 29mm
Test 1 6 053.8 RPM

9 614 RPM

10 782 RPM 8 995.5 RPM 9 058 RPM 8 969.7 RPM
Test 2 9 335 RPM 14 785 RPM 12 549 RPM 8 985.7 RPM 9 031.8 RPM 8 033.8 RPM

Test 3

9 343 RPM 14 243 RPM 9 562.3 RPM 8 893.9 RPM 10 515 RPM 9 181.4 RPM
Test 4 5 868 RPM 18 654 RPM 8 636.7 RPM 8 906.5 RPM 8 944.1 RPM 9 591 RPM
Test 5 9 307 RPM 14 255 RPM 8 663.8 RPM 8 897 RPM 8 996.8 RPM 9 139.6 RPM
Average 7 981.36 RPM 14 310.20 RPM 10 038.76 RPM 8 935.72 RPM 9 309.14 RPM 8 983.10 RPM

Conclusion

We conclude that by placing magnets next to an electric motor, the RPM of the motor increase. We moreover conclude that the closer the magnets are to the motor, the greater the RPM (with one exception, which requires further testing).

Our experiment was thus successful in proving our hypothesis. 

Application

When magnets are placed next to a motor, the RPM are increased without any extra power input.

This conclusion could have applications for engineering electric motors. In particular, we would propose innovations using external magnets that would increase the RPM. In designing these motors it will be especially important to reduce the distance between the motor and the external magnets. 

We live in a time in which new innovations in energy efficiency are increasingly vital. And so, as Aesop put it, "Necessity is the mother of invention."

 

Sources Of Error

- battery power loss over time

- motor speed when starting and stopping

- motor shaking

- next time measure the torque as well as the RPM

 

Citations

- Jared Owen, "How Does an Electric Motor Work? (DC Motor)," https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWulQ1ZSE3c.

- David MacAulay, The Way Things Work, Revised Edition (Clarion Books, 2023). 

- Science Max, "Electromagnet," https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaPfo2hwDSI.

 

Acknowledgement

Rowan Scruggs: for doing background research and designing the trifold

Caius Franco: for performing the tests, 3D printing the motor magnet jig, and entering the data

Amber and Mike Franco: for paying for the supplies

Mr. Casidy: for telling us funny jokes when we should have been working

Avery Guy: for acting as the consultant and mentor of our team

Ryan Scruggs: for tirelessly fixing all our typos

Mrs. Bouchard: for letting us tape the batteries together with her tape