What Substance Melts Ice the Fastest?

What substance will ice melt the fastest in, salt, sugar or baking soda?
Callum Aucoin Henry Parker
Grade 5

Presentation

No video provided

Hypothesis

Hypothesis: 

 

We think the salt will melt ice the fastest because we observe salt melting ice on the sidewalk in our natural world. 




Hypothesis - Free of Charge Creative Commons Office worker ...

2


 

Research

Background #1: Salt

 

When salt is added to ice or snow, it creates a saltwater solution that has a lower freezing point (that is -21.1 degrees celsius) than pure water.

 

File:Himalayan salt (coarse).jpg - Wikipedia

Background# 2: Baking Soda

 

When baking soda is added to ice and snow, it can create a fizzy, bubbly reaction, producing carbon dioxide gas, that also contributes to melting the ice faster than without baking soda. 

 Background #3: Sugar

 

Adding sugar to ice will cause it to melt faster because sugar, like salt, lowers the freezing point of water, making it harder for water to solidify into ice. 


 


 

Variables

Salt, baking soda, sugar

Procedure

 

 

Methodology:

 

  • Selected four equal size ceramic bowls
  • Placed 30 milliliters of salt in one bowl, 30 milliliters of sugar in one bowl and 30 milliliters of baking soda in the third bowl
  • The fourth bowl was the control with no substance 
  • Placed one machine made ice cube (equal sizes) in each of the four bowls 
  • The room temperature was 18 degrees celsius 


 

                                                                                                                            

Methodology - Free of Charge Creative Commons Keyboard image

Observations

Discussion: 

We observed that salt melts the ice the fastest followed by baking soda, then the control group, then the sugar

  • We think the salt melted the ice the fastest because it lowered the freezing point the most
  • We think sugar melted the ice slowest because sugar is a covalent compound meanwhile salt is a ionic compound

Attend CG SUPRT's May webinars on kids and money management ...

Analysis

Conclusion

Conclusion:

 

In conclusion the salt melted the ice the fastest with baking soda  coming in second and sugar coming in third.

Conclusions - Free of Charge Creative Commons Chalkboard image

11


 

Application

Future implications: 

 

 If you want a substance that will melt your ice quickly but not too fast go with baking soda.

Based on our experiment, you can actually use sugar to isolate ice                                                                                                                                                                                   

Bulletin | BC Training

12


 

Sources Of Error

Citations

Acknowledgement