SILVER

Ready, Set, Reaction

I will drop alka seltzer tablets into water of different temperatures and study the rate of the reaction. I want to find out whether it reacts faster in hot, cold or room temperature and why.
Shayan Choudhury
Grade 5

Hypothesis

The hypothesis is based on the fact that molecules can react when they have enough energy. Heating the molecules by increasing temperature enables the molecules to move faster. In this experiment by varying the temperature, I am capturing different energy levels of water molecules involved in the reaction. In hot water, the heat energy is transferred to the water molecules which makes them move faster. Thus, hot water facilitates the rate of the reaction compared to cold water.

 

 

Research

The chemical reaction that I decided to study is: 3NaHCO3 + C6H8O7 → C6H5Na3O7 + 3CO2 + 3H2O

I researched that heat transfers energy into molecules (in this case water) will move faster and they have more contact with the other chemical/s(in this case sodium bicarbonate and citric acid) meaning that the chemical reaction speeds up.

I also researched that mixing water and the ingredients of an Alka Seltzer tablet will have a reaction of carbon dioxide gas and water and sodium citrate.

Variables

 

Procedure

            

  1. Measure 100 mL each of cold water, room temperature water, hot water and tap water (control)
  2. Take 4 glass jars of the same dimension, place them on a stable surface and add the water from step 1 into separate jars.
  3. Measure the water temperature in each jar and record it in  column2  of Table 1a.
  4. Drop one Alka Seltzer tablet in each jar and start the timer.
  5. Stop the timer when the tablet has dissolved completely.
  6. Record the reaction times (in minutes and seconds) in column 3 of Table 1a.
  7. Repeat the above steps 2 more times and record them in Table 1b and Table 1c.

 

       The process will be recorded to show the stopwatch and the reaction. The tablet should be dropped in each jar at the same time as well. Then I have to wait for the reaction and note the rate of reaction for each jar. This information will be gathered from the video of the reaction.

Observations

I observed both physical and chemical changes occurred during the reactions. A solid tablet is dissolved in liquid water to release a gas called carbon dioxide. I have recorded the temperature and time in the tables below.

Table 1a: Record the reaction times Experiment I
Water Type Temperature (ºC) Time (in secs)

CO2 released (in cm)

Control 22.2 0 N/A
Cold  7 89 N/A
Room Temperature 22.4 53 N/A
Hot 72.2 30 N/A

 

Table 1b: Record the reaction times Experiment II
Water Type Temperature (ºC) Time (in secs)

CO2 released (in cm)

Control 22.4 0 N/A
Cold  6.5 90 N/A
Room Temperature 22.4 53 N/A
Hot 71.3 33 N/A

 

Table 1c: Record the reaction times Experiment III
Water Type Temperature (ºC) Time (in secs)

CO2 released (in cm)

Control 22.2 0 N/A
Cold  8.2 92 N/A
Room Temperature 22.5 52 N/A
Hot 71.9 32 N/A

 

 

Carbon dioxide is released as a product of the reaction I had to come up with a method to measure the amount of carbon dioxide released. Therefore I used another parameter which is "how high do the carbon dioxide bubbles float up?" 

I observed the carbon dioxide bubbles but they didn't reach above the water and hence I was unable to measure the height. In addition, the tablet is completely dissolved in hot water whereas it was not the case for room temperature water and cold water.

Analysis

In this experiment, the jar with the hot water reacted the fastest and it ended the first. My explanation for this would be that the hot water molecules have a lot of energy in the form of heat so they start the soonest and they end the fastest because the water molecules have burned out all their energy at the start. The jar with the room temperature water reacted right after the one with the hot water because it is a mix of hot water and cold water so the water does have the energy to react fast but not as fast as the one with hot water. This sustains the second-longest because it does not have much energy so it can not be burned out at the beginning of the experiment. The jar with cold water did not have any additional energy so the reaction started the latest and sustained the longest. I also noticed that the jar with the hot water dissolved the Alka Seltzer tablet completely while the Alka Seltzer tablet did not dissolve into a clear solution in the jars with cold water and room temperature water.

Conclusion

My experiments show that increase in temperature speeds up the chemical reaction. Thus, the rate of reaction was fastest in hot water compared to cold and room temperature water. 

Application

I always wondered how pills cured my stomach aches. Studying this chemical reaction has helped me understand this process. The pills have sodium bicarbonate which is a base and goes into your stomach and neutralizes the acid (HCl) in your stomach. In other words, the base which is sodium bicarbonate neutralizes the acid in your stomach.

Sources Of Error

There can several possible sources of error for this experiment. I have listed them below:

  1. Random errors:  We have repeated the experiment three times to control for it.
  2. Systematic error. The temperature of water used in this experiment, not able to control it.
  3. Environmental error. We have performed the experiment in the same room within the same hour to control any environmental factor.
  4. Procedural error. All the experiments were done by me to minimize any procedural error
  5. Estimation error. This type of error could be from reading a ruler differently, not able to control it

Acknowledgement

I am very grateful to my teachers at Sunalta School for giving me this opportunity to participate in the Science Fair. I enjoyed working together with my Mom on this project.